How Do I Insure An Investment Property?

Written by April Weismann on 03/18/2026 12:38 PM in Business Insurance,. Commercial Insurance.

 New Hampshire continues to experience strong growth in both residential and commercial property investment. From residential developments in Manchester to industrial properties in Bedford, new investment projects are emerging across the state.

If you’re involved in investment properties in Bedford—or anywhere in New Hampshire—it’s essential to ensure those assets are properly insured. Insurance plays a critical role in protecting significant investments from a wide range of potential losses. Here’s some advice on how to make sure your investment properties are adequately covered. 

real estate investment

 

How Should I Insure My New Hampshire Investment Properties?

Covering Damage to the Property

One of the most common risks for investment properties is physical damage to the building itself. Events such as fire, wind, lightning, hail, frozen pipes, and vandalism can lead to costly repairs—and in severe cases, may result in a total loss.

A striking example of how unexpected these risks can be occurred this winter in Nashua, when falling ice punctured a natural gas line, causing an explosion that destroyed the building.

Protecting your property from these types of losses typically requires the right kind of investment property insurance. Depending on the property and its use, coverage options may include landlord insurance, apartment complex insurance, commercial property insurance, office building insurance, and other specialized policies. These policies are designed to help safeguard your investment by covering a wide range of common and unexpected property-related risks.

How Much Coverage is Enough?

How much to insure a building for is not the same as what you could sell it for or what the city or town assesses it at. Property insurance is based on the cost to rebuild the structure from the ground up. 

If your rental or investment property is underinsured, the financial consequences following a loss can be significant.
 

What Happens If Your Building Is Underinsured?

1. Your claim payment may be reduced

If the cost to repair or rebuild exceeds your policy’s building limit, the insurance company will generally pay only up to that limit. Any remaining costs become the property owner’s responsibility.

This situation is especially common when:
  • Construction costs have increased
  • The property hasn’t been re‑valued in years
  • Improvements or renovations weren’t reported to the insurer

2. Coinsurance penalties may apply

Many rental and commercial property policies include a coinsurance requirement, meaning the building must be insured to a certain percentage of its replacement cost. If it’s not, the carrier may reduce the claim payment—even for partial losses.

In short, even if the damage is below the policy limit, underinsurance can still result in a reduced payout. Talk with your agent about suggestions for determining an accurate replacement limit. 

Covering Accidents on the Property

Another important risk for investment property owners is the possibility of accidents occurring on the premises. As the property owner—and investor—you may be held financially responsible if someone is injured on your property.

These incidents can range from common slips on ice or falls in the stairway to less obvious situations, such as children climbing on construction equipment or injuries caused by falling light fixtures.
 
Unfortunately, this is a risk that nearly every property owner faces. Accidents can happen at single‑family rental homes, large commercial buildings, and even vacant land. In some cases, individuals may attempt to pursue a claim even if they were not authorized to be on the property at the time of the injury.
 
General liability insurance is designed to help protect against many of these types of claims. While many businesses carry general liability coverage that applies both on and off their premises, property investors often carry a policy specifically tailored to accidents that occur on their owned properties. Having the right liability coverage in place helps protect you from costly legal expenses and potential settlements, allowing you to focus on managing and growing your investment.
 

Given that you are entrusting tenants with your investment, it is strongly recommended that property owners consider an umbrella policy- a commercial umbrella policy if the property is owned in a business name or a personal umbrella, if owned individually. As a property owner, you could be held financially responsible for events such as a tenant-hosted happy hour VIP clients, or an after-prom party at your apartment complex.

 
When it comes to protecting your personal and business assets from the actions of others,  additional liability protection is often a wise investment.
 
building under magnifying glass
 

Is Loss of Rental Income Covered on an Investment Property Policy?

When you invest in an income‑producing property, the goal is straightforward: generate revenue. But that income stream can be interrupted if the building is damaged and cannot be occupied while repairs or rebuilding are underway. This is where loss of income coverage—also referred to as rental income or business income coverage—can play an important role.

Loss of income coverage is a key component of many investment property insurance policies, but its application can vary by carrier and policy form. Understanding how this coverage works for your specific policy is essential.

The Basics of Loss of Rental Income Coverage

Loss of rental income coverage may help replace lost revenue when income is reduced due to a covered claim, such as fire, smoke damage, or another covered peril. A critical requirement is that there be direct physical damage to the building itself, and that the damage renders it uninhabitable.

Coverage typically applies during the reasonable period of restoration—the time it should take to repair or rebuild the property following a covered loss.

What Loss of Rental Income Does Not Cover

Loss of rental income coverage does not apply in all situations. Common exclusions include:

  • Vacancy caused by market conditions
  • Losses resulting from wear and tear or deferred maintenance (for example, a roof leak due to age)
  • Loss of income caused by uncovered events, such as flooding, which is not included under most investment property policies unless separate flood insurance is in place

Because coverage terms, limits, and exclusions vary, it’s important to review your policy to understand how this coverage applies to your specific property.

Why This Matters to You

Investment properties represent significant financial commitments. Unexpected losses—from property damage, liability claims, or income interruptions—can quickly impact cash flow, property value, and long‑term investment goals.

Having the right insurance in place helps protect you from costly repairs, legal expenses, and lost income, providing peace of mind that your investment is protected no matter what comes your way.

Get the Right Insurance for Your Investment Properties

While nearly all investment properties should be insured, there’s no “one‑size‑fits‑all” solution. The right coverage depends on the type of property you own, how it’s used, and the risks specific to that location. If you own multiple types of property, you may need more than one policy to ensure adequate protection.

Insuring investment property is more involved than purchasing a standard homeowners policy and requires coverage tailored to your specific risks.

If you need help insuring investment properties anywhere in New Hampshire or New England, the independent agents at HPM Insurance are here to help. We’ve worked with property investors throughout the state—from Bedford to the White Mountains—and have experience insuring a wide range of residential and commercial properties. Our team will take the time to understand your property and help you select coverage and policy options designed to protect it. Contact us today.

Possibly related posts: